One of the most memorable consultations I’ve had recently was in my rapid access heart failure clinic. A lady came to see me with swollen ankles, breathlessness and all the features that made me worry about heart failure. However when she had her echocardiogram scan it was essentially normal. There is a list of possibilities I think of in this scenario, but before I could start working through them, she smiled and said, ‘I think I know what’s caused it.’ Patients almost always know their own bodies better than any doctor ever can. Where it is clinically appropriate, I’m a strong believer in helping patients manage their own treatment according to their symptoms and home measurements such as blood pressure or heart rhythm. A well-informed patient with agency regarding their care is far more likely to feel and do better in my view.
I digress. She then went on to tell me that she had been chewing large quantities of liquorice root from a health food shop for a couple of months, and had felt rather addicted to it. Whilst waiting for the appointment to see me, she put 2 and 2 together and realised the timing simply couldn’t be a coincidence.
So, she stopped the liquorice root.
The swelling disappeared.
This was in fact the second time I’ve seen this. Liquorice root contains glycyrrhizin, which inhibits an enzyme (11β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type 2 if you’re interested!). The end result is that the hormone cortisol acts like the hormone aldosterone, causing the kidneys to retain sodium and water while losing potassium. The consequences can include:
● ankle swelling
● high blood pressure
● low potassium
● trigger abnormal heart rhythms (arrhythmias)
● worsen heart failure
Fortunately, stopping the liquorice usually reverses the problem. Interestingly, several of our most effective medicines for heart failure and high blood pressure work by blocking the effects of aldosterone. Excess liquorice is, in many respects, doing exactly the opposite.. It is worth emphasising that deglycyrrhizinated liquorice (DGL) doesn’t have the same cardiovascular effects because the glycyrrhizin has been removed.
Liquorice isn’t unique. There are a surprising number of ‘natural’ products that as a cardiologist I worry about.
Bitter orange (synephrine), often marketed for weight loss, fat burning and pre-workout supplements, has the potential to cause increased heart rate, raised blood pressure, palpitations and arrhythmias, especially when combined with caffeine.
Many ‘natural energy’ and pre-workout supplements contain very high doses of caffeine, which can cause palpitations, atrial fibrillation in susceptible people, anxiety and raised blood pressure.
Yohimbine, found in some bodybuilding and fat-loss products can cause tachycardia, hypertension, anxiety and arrhythmias. It has been banned in the UK from general sale but my understanding is it can still be prescribed unlicensed.
St John’s Wort, not because it damages the heart directly, but because it’s one of the commonest causes of clinically important drug interactions. It speeds up the breakdown of many medicines in the body, reducing the effectiveness of medications including:
- DOACs
- warfarin
- digoxin
- some statins
- calcium-channel blockers
Ginkgo biloba is very common, and again the biggest concern isn’t the heart itself but the increased bleeding risk when combined with commonly prescribed heart drugs including:
- aspirin
- clopidogrel
- warfarin
- DOACs
High dose garlic supplements can cause the same issue.
Red yeast rice is an interesting one I get asked about a lot in clinic, and a number of my patients take it. The commonest reason is that people take it for raised cholesterol as they don’t want to take statins, and think they’re avoiding statins by doing so. However a little known fact is that red yeast rice naturally contains monacolin K, which is chemically identical to lovastatin (admittedly we do not use this in the UK, but it makes the point). Whilst undoubtedly natural, it can produce exactly the same side effects as a statin, while the dose may be highly variable between products. Ironically, some people are therefore unknowingly taking a naturally occurring statin while believing they’re avoiding statins altogether.
This last point cannot be over emphasised. I don’t want to come across as anti-supplements, I am certainly not, and take some myself daily. However, one important difference between medicines and food supplements is regulation. Prescription medicines have to demonstrate exactly what’s in each tablet, at exactly what dose, and that every batch is manufactured to the same standard. Supplements are regulated differently, meaning the amount of active ingredient, and sometimes even its purity, can vary considerably between products
Whilst I’m on statins, I had an interesting question from a GP member of my blog recently about women and statins, so just a heads up that this will be next week’s topic.
It’s also worth mentioning that supplements can interact with heart medication, for example, liquorice taken alongside diuretics may worsen low potassium levels, while liquorice combined with digoxin may increase the risk of abnormal heart rhythms. Some herbal products can also interfere with anticoagulants (see above).
I’m not anti-supplement. Some have evidence of benefit in selected situations. But I am very much against the assumption that because something is sold in a health food shop it must be harmless. Always mention supplements to your doctor. When I ask patients what medication they’re taking, many reply ‘None.’ Five minutes later they tell me about their turmeric capsules, St John’s Wort, magnesium, ashwagandha, collagen powder, mushroom coffee and three different herbal teas. From a doctor’s perspective, those are medications too. They can have physiological effects, they can interact with prescription drugs, and they can occasionally cause the very symptoms we’re trying to investigate.
Fortunately, in my patient’s case, no lasting harm was done, but it is a fascinating story and a great reminder of the importance of the patient story! Three things I’d recommend:
• Tell your doctor or pharmacist about every supplement you take.
• Don’t assume “natural” automatically means safe, or effective.
• If you develop new symptoms after starting a supplement, stop and consider whether the two may be related (after seeking medical advice where appropriate).
Interestingly, this week’s research video is about a new heart failure treatment that works by blocking the effects of aldosterone – the very same hormone pathway that excess liquorice activates.